Latest News

  • Jungheinrich’s ERE 225i compact truck wins Red Dot Award
  • New Hyster A Series Lift Trucks Scale to Industry Challenges
  • Clark introduces new high-lift pallet truck with mono mast and initial lift
  • New Modulean Rack End Boards, from workplace visual communications and safety products specialists Beaverswood
  • Jungheinrich introduces POWERLiNE lithium-ion trucks to market 
  • Home
  • News
  • Materials Handling
  • Health & Safety
  • Notice Board
  • Multimedia
    • Audio
    • Book Review
    • T.V.
    • Video
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • follow
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Google+
    • Pinterest
    • RSS Feed
    • Linked
    • Youtube

Excise penalty regime is ‘unfit for purpose’ & will drive 3PLs out of business

Jun 16, 2013 Warehousing Ireland News 0


The United Kingdom Warehousing Association (UKWA) – the trade association representing the interests of some 700 UK-based third party logistics (3PL) specialists – is warning that Her Majesty’s Revenue & Customs (HMRC) is imposing “draconian” sanctions on companies in the excise goods  supply chain that will drive long established and honest firms out of business.

The Association says that logistics service businesses – including third party warehouse keepers and hauliers – risk incurring “crippling” duty assessments and fines if they make any procedural error relating to any ‘duty-suspended’ excise goods that they may store or distribute on behalf of their clients.

Alan Powell, UKWA’s advisor on excise matters, explains: “Any breach of duty suspension arrangements creates a ‘duty point’ and means that the company which created that ’duty point’ has liability for all the duty owed. In addition, the company would also face a ‘wrong doing’ penalty of up to 100 per cent of the duty owed for handling the goods if the duty isn’t paid at the ‘duty point.’

He continues:  “Any company that accidentally ‘ticks the wrong box’ while goods are under duty suspense – whether in production, holding or movement –will create a ‘duty point’. And if the company doesn’t pay the duty at that time, a liability of up to 100% of the duty will be incurred for ‘holding’ duty-unpaid goods.

“Furthermore, everyone in the supply chain that handles the goods on which the duty hasn’t been paid is similarly liable to the penalty.”

“Given that excise duty is so high, the risk of such liability can be damaging at best and catastrophic in the worst case.”  

The situation has arisen as a result of laws passed in 2010 that requires duty to be paid at the earliest of stipulated duty points, including any breach of duty suspension arrangements.  At the same time, HMRC were given powers to raise “wrong-doing” penalties, which are linked to 100% of the duty “potentially at risk”.

“Everyone accepts that HMRC needs strong powers to deter non-compliance, especially in the light of excise frauds, but such powers must be proportionate and should not jeopardise honest businesses that simply make a genuine error,” says Alan Powell.

“However,” he continues, “we are seeing a growing number of cases where long-established and legitimate businesses have fallen foul of the new penalty regime.”

He adds: “HMRC says that the regime is meant to deter businesses from gaining an unfair advantage and to ‘change the behavior’ of the non-compliant.  But compliant businesses are being punished disproportionately for occasional human or system errors. ”

HMRC contends that it is constrained to enforce the law as it stands but has undertaken  to review the proportionality of the penalty regime.

Following recent high-level discussions with industry, HMRC confirmed that it “is keen on having a system that hits fraudsters but does not unduly impact on legitimate trade. Nevertheless, this balance is not easy and no assumptions should be made that any changes will result from the review.”

UKWA believes that the random creation of ‘duty points’ as a result of genuine error in the supply chain and the resultant huge assessments and penalties incurred, render the law totally unfit for purpose, as Alan Powell explains:

“We have taken initial legal advice from senior counsel about this problem and feel that, as it stands, UK law is inconsistent with the purpose of overarching EU law and clearly lacking proportionality”.

Roger Williams, UKWA’s chief executive officer, comments: “The current rules evidently do not deter fraudsters but put legitimate business at great risk.  We will fight this all the way for our members”.

Tweet

  • tweet
transport logistic 2013 – Broader international scope & rising optimism Record number of visitors attend WTG open day

Warehousing Ireland

Related articles
  • Jungheinrich’s ERE 225i compact truck wins Red Dot Award
    Jungheinrich’s ERE 225i compact...

    Jul 03, 2022 Comments Off on Jungheinrich’s ERE 225i compact truck wins Red Dot Award

  • New Hyster A Series Lift Trucks Scale to Industry Challenges
    New Hyster A Series Lift Trucks Scale...

    Jul 03, 2022 Comments Off on New Hyster A Series Lift Trucks Scale to Industry Challenges

  • Clark introduces new high-lift pallet truck with mono mast and initial lift
    Clark introduces new high-lift pallet...

    Jul 03, 2022 Comments Off on Clark introduces new high-lift pallet truck with mono mast and initial lift

More in this category
  • Ideally-located & secure HGV storage & warehousing site for rent at Cranford, near Kettering
    Ideally-located & secure HGV...

    Jun 26, 2021 Comments Off on Ideally-located & secure HGV storage & warehousing site for rent at Cranford, near Kettering

  • tesa packaging tape brings food storage in from the cold
    tesa packaging tape brings food storage...

    Jul 07, 2019 Comments Off on tesa packaging tape brings food storage in from the cold

  • Yale Europe Materials Handling expands tow tractor range
    Yale Europe Materials Handling expands...

    May 13, 2018 Comments Off on Yale Europe Materials Handling expands tow tractor range


Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Tweets by @warehousingIrl

Recent Posts

Forklift market rebound causes gap between order intakes and shipments

Forklift market rebound causes gap between order intakes and shipments

Nov 24, 2021 Comments Off on Forklift market rebound causes gap between order intakes and shipments

Long-term forecast of global market in 2028 raised by 40% APAC accounts for 54% of 2021 forklift shipments E-commerce, digitalization, and electrification will drive the market  Updated...
The new Visuclean vinyl from Beaverswood

The new Visuclean vinyl from Beaverswood

May 01, 2021 Comments Off on The new Visuclean vinyl from Beaverswood

New Modulean Lite shadow boards from Beaverswood

New Modulean Lite shadow boards from Beaverswood

Nov 14, 2020 Comments Off on New Modulean Lite shadow boards from Beaverswood

Hyster Europe expands its range of electric counterbalance lift trucks

Hyster Europe expands its range of electric...

Sep 13, 2020 Comments Off on Hyster Europe expands its range of electric counterbalance lift trucks

Linde Training Solutions – Well Trained Without Fail

Linde Training Solutions – Well Trained...

Aug 09, 2020 Comments Off on Linde Training Solutions – Well Trained Without Fail

Recent Posts

RHA launches tail lift safety guidance

RHA launches tail lift safety guidance

May 15, 2021 Comments Off on RHA launches tail lift safety guidance

The Road Haulage Association in the UK has published long-awaited guidance to improve safety around the use of tail lifts. The Tail Lift and Pallet Truck Guidance Document released aims to...
Axial Properties Ltd fined €80,000 following serious incident in Clonee warehouse

Axial Properties Ltd fined €80,000 following...

Nov 22, 2020 Comments Off on Axial Properties Ltd fined €80,000 following serious incident in Clonee warehouse

New Modulean Lite shadow boards from Beaverswood

New Modulean Lite shadow boards from Beaverswood

Nov 14, 2020 Comments Off on New Modulean Lite shadow boards from Beaverswood

How to safely buy a used ATEX forklift

How to safely buy a used ATEX forklift

Jul 12, 2020 Comments Off on How to safely buy a used ATEX forklift

A-SAFE launches new hygiene partition for industrial facilities

A-SAFE launches new hygiene partition for...

May 31, 2020 Comments Off on A-SAFE launches new hygiene partition for industrial facilities

Newsletter

Recent Posts

  • Jungheinrich’s ERE 225i compact truck wins Red Dot Award
  • New Hyster A Series Lift Trucks Scale to Industry Challenges
  • Clark introduces new high-lift pallet truck with mono mast and initial lift
  • New Modulean Rack End Boards, from workplace visual communications and safety products specialists Beaverswood
  • Jungheinrich introduces POWERLiNE lithium-ion trucks to market 
  • Garbe Industrial Real Estate hands over new Warehouse to Iron Mountain in Germany
  • BotsAndUs White Paper on Warehouse Management Systems
  • New Hyster Forklift set for launch at Logimat 2022
  • iF Design Award for Jungheinrich’s ERE 225i 
  • Groundbreaking ceremony for logistics centre in Bitterfeld-Wolfen 
  • Groundbreaking ceremony for new Jungheinrich plant at Chomutov, Czech Republic
  • CKF design and build Auto Packer cell for bio-bean, the world’s largest recycler of coffee grounds
  • Gowan Group moves to new impressive new facility at Citywest
  • Jungheinrich starts 2022 financial year in line with expectations
  • EPAL pallet production reaches record levels in 2021
Copyright 2020 Warehousing Ireland / All rights reserved