Shipping costs for cars in containers were once perceived to be far more expensive than RORO; but a new study illustrates that this is not necessarily the case anymore and that there are clear advantages to containerisation, both in terms of transit speed and safe delivery.
“Historically, RORO has always been the dominant option for shipping vehicles in volume, but in more recent years, containerisation has emerged strongly as a viable alternative,” says Paul Donaldson, Managing Director of leading racking systems manufacturer, Trans-Rak International. “This new report demonstrates where the numbers clearly add up for containerisation and confirms that it makes commercial sense for carriers and carmakers to take a more strategic view, rather than simply defaulting to RORO.”
Presented as an academic dissertation to the World Maritime University in Malmӧ, Sweden, by Sean Xu, Evaluation of Shipping Finished Automotive in Multimodal Containers*, examines the logistics of door-to-door automotive transportation, investigates the gains and ‘cost per car’ of RORO compared to shipping cars in containers, and highlights the important role played by flexible, re-usable racking in making the case for containerisation.
The report confirms that when it comes to shipping a consistently large quantity of vehicles in regular slots, RORO may still fit the bill; however, where there are changes to schedules and fluctuating volumes, containerisation often proves more the convenient and cost-efficient choice. Larger RORO vessels must follow deep sea routes, travel more slowly and there are fewer ports with RORO terminals. In contrast, container ships have more frequent sailings, with quicker transit times and a wider choice of ports.
Clearly, containerisation is usually the best option for high value vehicles which need to be delivered from A to B in pristine condition. In a RORO environment, vehicles are subject to considerably more handling in the course of being driven on and off deck and therefore more vulnerable to damage. This, added to constant exposure the elements throughout the shipping process, means that even for mass market vehicles, it is essential to factor in additional costs for damage repairs as well as time lost through subsequent delays in transit.
Wooden systems are still widely used to ship cars in containers, but these are relatively expensive to build, often not reliable or safe and are for single use only. By switching to steel systems which are flexible, robust and re-usable, significant cost savings begin to kick in, even after factoring in the initial outlay and product training. According to Paul Donaldson, racks manufactured for shippers almost ten years ago are still in continual use.
Not only is the cargo protected, more cars can be fitted into each container, loading and unloading is much quicker and the racking can be dismantled for the return journey, fitting 65 pods in each container.
Summing up Paul Donaldson says: “It’s great that an independent assessment comes to the clear conclusion that RORO is not always King; where safe and secure delivery, speed of transit and final destination are prime considerations, cars in containers is the way to go.”
Sep 20, 2020 Comments Off on TIMCON President commends industry response to Brexit
Sep 20, 2020 Comments Off on More lift truck users taking lithium-ion option
Sep 20, 2020 Comments Off on LiBiao’s ‘Mini Yellow’ mobile robots bring game-changing sorting solution to Europe
Aug 03, 2020 Comments Off on European Pallet Association (EPAL) warns on Brexit pallet delays
Jul 12, 2020 Comments Off on Streamlining efficiency with paperless warehouse processes
Jun 25, 2020 Comments Off on How true collaboration and passion for recycling paved the way for plastic pallets market
Sep 13, 2020 Comments Off on Hyster Europe expands its range of electric counterbalance lift trucksHyster Europe has extended its range of electric counterbalance lift trucks with the introduction of nine new three- and four-wheel forklift models for lifts up to 3.5 tonnes. The Hyster...
Aug 09, 2020 Comments Off on Linde Training Solutions – Well Trained Without Fail
Aug 03, 2020 Comments Off on Warehouse Strategy, Design & Operation for a Post-Covid-19 World
Jul 12, 2020 Comments Off on How to safely buy a used ATEX forklift
Jun 25, 2020 Comments Off on BYD Forklifts appoints UK & Ireland Country Manager
Jul 12, 2020 Comments Off on How to safely buy a used ATEX forkliftPre-owned explosion proof lift trucks can be useful additions to potentially explosive operations, but how do you know they are safe and are they dangerous? Darren Boiling from safety...
May 31, 2020 Comments Off on A-SAFE launches new hygiene partition for industrial facilities
Mar 25, 2020 Comments Off on Hospitality casualties could join warehousing workforce says UKWA
Mar 08, 2020 Comments Off on New Visusafe range from Beaverswood offers improved levels of workplace safety & protection
Dec 01, 2019 Comments Off on Driver awareness with benefits of the Hyster Fortens lift truck